For me, Thanksgiving is all about the food. I know, it’s bold statement but it’s one I will stick by. Family, being thankful- all of that rocks- but I love my family and count my blessings every day. The Thanksgiving Feast, on the other hand, is a once-a-year thing.
I think we need more feast days on our calendar but for now, we only have the one and I try to make the most of it each year. I especially enjoy the cooking on Thanksgiving. Spending the day in a cozy kitchen while first the parade, then the football game play barely audibly in the background is well up my alley.
But, as you know, I am always one to try and improve on a good thing, to give the envelope a tiny nudge, to gild the lilly. And I thought that I might just be able to improve on nature’s prefect food: stuffing. (Or dressing if you prefer; I want to go on record here as saying that both are correct and that I wouldn’t take a side in that particular civil war for love nor money.)
There are nearly as many recipes for stuffing as there are cooks and every family has there own sacrosanct version. My family has two, actually. My dad makes an oyster dressing that’s so good I some times have actual dreams about it. My Mama, Carrie and I have a super-secret traditional stuffing recipe that we adore and which we share with NO ONE. Not since my Mama gave it to her sister Shirley, who then promptly submitted it to her church’s self-publish, fund-raiser cookbook. (Apparently there are no secrets between Aunt Shirley and the Southern Baptist Ladies Auxiliary.)
So why, you are now asking yourselves, am I even bothering with a new stuffing recipe? Because I must. The idea for this stuffing came to me a couple of weeks ago and I just couldn’t get it out of my head. So I scheduled an early Thanksgiving for last Monday (widely referred to as ‘Fakesgiving’ by those in attendance) and spent the day perfecting my recipe.
And now, I present it to you, my lovely, loyal readers.
Here’s what you’ll need:
1 box Trader Joe’s Pumpkin Bread and Muffin Mix (if you don’t live near a Trader Joe’s, substitute another brand)
2 French baguettes, torn into bite-sized pieces and allowed to sit out overnight to dry out
1 skillet of corn bread (home made or from a box, it matters little as long as it isn’t sweet)
1 pound breakfast sausage, browned (or 2 pounds if you really like sausage in your stuffing as I do.)
4 cups chicken or turkey stock
1 handful dried cranberries
1 heaping tablespoon dried sage (or more to taste)
Salt and pepper to taste
Instructions:
Prepare Trader Joe’s Pumpkin Bread Mix according to the package directions then pour into a large glass pyrex dish and cook until an inserted toothpick comes out clean.
Meanwhile, prepare a skillet of corn bread according to your favorite recipe, omitting any sugar.
If you failed to leave your baguette pieces out overnight to dry, now is a good time to pop them in the oven at 350 for ten minutes or so to dry them out. Then place them in a large mixing bowl.
Crumble and add one half the pan of pumpkin bread to the bowl, along with all the crumbled corn bread and a handful of dried cranberries. (Save the other half of the pumpkin bread for breakfast tomorrow.)
Add the browned sausage to the bowl and a couple of teaspoons of the fat from the pan.
And three cups of the chicken stock.
And two eggs to help bind everything together.
Stir to combine. The stuffing should be damp but not wet. If you’re stuffing is too dry, add more chicken stock, a bit at a time, until you active the dampness you want. Then taste for seasoning and add salt and pepper to taste.
This recipe made enough stuffing to stuff a ten pound bird with enough left over to fill a large casserole dish that we cooked alongside the turkey.
We were so hungry by the time dinner was ready that we completely forgot to take any pics of the finished turkey. D’oh!
The stuffing that comes out of the bird is just. so. good. It’s like all of Thanksgiving condensed into a delicious, complex dish. Although it’s not sweet, there are sweet undertones that combine so nicely with the savory, sausage-y, sage-i-ness. Pumpkin, cranberries, sausage and turkey juices…what’s not to love?
Give it a try on your next Fakesgiving or even on Thanksgiving Day itself. In the meantime, help me come up with a name for this recipe? Leave your suggestions in the comments.








{ 14 comments… read them below or add one }
This looks tasty! My grandmother makes our dressing with day old cornbread and biscuits. I like the idea of pumpkin bread and sausage in there too. I may have to make a batch when we get home. Any chance your dad would share his oyster dressing recipe? My dad is living on the Eastern Shore right now and loves any excuse to eat more oysters!
Today I went to my LTJ (Local Trader Joes) and lo and behold…..they were already sold out of their pumpkin bread mix!!! Go figure. They did, however, still have an ample supply of their fresh cranberry sauce and the one with the orange in it too. If you haven’t tried it you must. It it sooooo good on a turkey sandwich the day after thanksgiving …or fakesgiving.
It sounds amazing–pity it has sausage, though, since that would actually kill my mother. But, otherwise? Yum!
(And I agree. Thanksgiving is all about the food.)
I’m with you – real or fake, Thanksgiving is all about the feast. Can’t bring myself to give up the family stuffing, but yours looks really good. Gave up stuffing the bird at all though. I just fill a big casserole dish that goes into the oven when the bird has about an hour to go. I add liquid from the bottom of the turkey pan, and it tastes even better than if it had cooked in the bird (way better I think!)
Any news on the donkey foal? Inquiring minds want to know…
Sorry, but stuffing should be stale challah, craisins soaked in bourbon, and halved fresh peeled chestnuts…along with the mirepoix, smaltz, a single egg and more bourbon.
That’s the problem with Thanksgiving…everyone has their “thing” that has to be just so, or the holiday isn’t the same.
Deb, you can easily leave the sausage out. I love it but I do not wish to kill your mom.
How about “Pumpkin Bread and Sausage Dressing” ….since those are two most noteable ingredients without getting too wordy by including cornbread? I just started Weight Watchers but this sounds too good to pass by!
This is so going on my Turkey Day table.
I hope Carrie and Ted like this stuffing, It sounds great~
Oh, sweet mercy, this looks good! I won’t be able to try it for Thanksgiving, as my brother-in-law is making his mom’s fantastic recipe dressing, but I plan to do a Fakesgiving soon to test this out. Maybe we’ll make this the whole meal….
Being raised in the south (Alabama), I prefer cornbread dressing. We don’t put sugar in our cornbread. Cook the cornbread, crumble it up in a big bowl, add onions, celery, poultry season, lots of sage, black pepper, salt, chicken broth , chicken torned in small pieces. You also can add biscuits or loaf bread if you don’t have enough cornbread. Mix it all up together. Brown until golden. Every region has their own traditions and favorites.
so going to make this, but add some green chilies and smoked paprika, chili powder to the mix!
OH MY GOD!!!!!! Ok…for this stuffing I shall suffer the joint pain that comes with gluten…For you, Susie, have tempted me beyond my limits!! Curse you you culinary siren songstress Susan Gibbs. Curse you…
And for names…how about Not Yo Mama’s Stuffin’! (and it must have the exclamation point because I know how much you love them)